Jump to content

Wikipedia:Wikipedia Signpost/Drafts/Why Wikidata should move from CC0 to the ODbL

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia



Why Wikidata should move from CC0 to the ODbL

Why Wikidata should move from CC0 to the ODbL

Sharing is caring

A solution for this problem would be to move to a copyleft license. The Open Database License (ODbL), for instance, was designed for datasets such as Wikidata, and has been used most notably on OpenStreetMap. ODbL's "ShareAlike" provisions (much like CC BY-SA) would be a tremendous step forward for our project, as it would ensure that Wikidata and its contributors are credited and that any derivations of this work will be released freely for all.

We should not fear vain threats made by those who wish to use us as mere free labor for their enterprises. Wikidata's mission is not "to be the most used dataset in the industry". Its purpose goes way beyond that. We are translating knowledge into structured knowledge.

We should not bend to the power of industry monopolists. No amount of venture capital or ill-disguised "donations" — which are really investments made with certain expectations in return — should interfere with our goal of making knowledge accessible. In this context, accessibility means "trickling down" freedoms; every downstream user needs to have the same guarantees we are granting upstream.

Ideally, this should not be a controversial point. All other Wikimedia projects are copylefted, with the conspicuous absence of Wikidata. Perhaps we should start asking why that is, whose interests are benefited from weak licensing choices and start organizing ourselves to fix this.